Mouthfeel Is the Missing Ingredient in Better-For-You Innovation

For years, better-for-you innovation has been framed as a nutrition problem: reduce the sugar, add the protein, cut the fat. But ask any product developer where reformulation actually goes wrong, and the answer is rarely the nutrition panel. It’s the second bite. The gritty protein bar. The icy, weeping “healthy” ice cream. The fibre-fortified snack that feels like eating cardboard. Nutrition gets a product trialled once. Texture decides whether anyone comes back for a second box.
Texture Has to Be Designed In, Not Bolted On
Joseph Lake, Vice President of Product Development and Food Design at Ingredion, makes a point that should reshape how NPD teams brief a project: texture isn’t something you fix at the end of development, it’s something you have to design for from the very beginning. Once a formulation is locked around a nutritional target, it’s often too late to meaningfully rescue the mouthfeel: the problem needs to be built around from day one, not patched over once the “healthy” version already tastes wrong.
This is exactly the lesson that shaped my own work on M&M Products Ltd, where the real challenge wasn’t hitting a nutrition target, it was protecting the sensory experience people already loved while getting there. Read the full case study here.
The Science Behind Fixing “Healthy” Texture
Nowhere is this more visible than in reduced-fat and plant-based product development. Take healthy ice cream: when fat is reduced or replaced with protein- or carbohydrate-based substitutes, formulators are fighting to preserve two things at once: partial coalescence (the fat structure that gives ice cream its body) and overall structural stability. Research has shown that complexes such as microparticulated soy protein hydrolysates combined with xanthan gum can rebuild that structure by forming dense aggregates that stabilise the ice cream matrix, improving creaminess, reducing grittiness, and slowing melt rate, all of which directly increase consumer acceptance of low-fat and plant-based versions (Yan et al., 2021).
At its core, this is a question of oral processing. The interaction between mechanical breakdown, colloidal destabilisation, and the sensory signals our brain interprets as taste and texture during eating (Feron & Salles, 2018; Wang & Chen, 2017). Oral tribology, which is the study of friction, wear, and lubrication inside the mouth, helps explain why some “healthy” reformulations feel wrong even when nothing has changed on the ingredient label. Astringency, for example, is a friction-driven sensation caused by reduced lubrication in the mouth, often triggered by the polyphenol-rich ingredients used in cleaner formulations. The dry, chalky mouthfeel so many consumers associate with “healthy” isn’t imagined, it’s measurable.
Kokumi: The Sensation Every Consumer Misses Without Knowing Its Name
There is a concept that rarely makes it onto an NPD brief but that sits at the heart of almost every reformulation failure. Kokumi.
I flagged it as a coming focus in my annual Newstalk food industry trend round-up in early 2025, and it has since moved from niche food science vocabulary into active reformulation strategy at the category level. It deserves far more attention than it currently gets in development conversations.
Kokumi- from the Japanese, translating roughly as “rich taste” or “mouthfulness”-is not a standalone taste the way sweet or sour are. It’s a sensation triggered by specific peptides that deepens, extends, and amplifies the flavours already present. The result is a velvety, lingering, full-bodied richness, what people reach for when they say a dish “has body,” or describe something as deeply satisfying in a way that goes beyond the individual ingredients. It is the experience of complexity without being able to identify its source.
Consumers cannot name it. But they notice immediately when it’s gone.
Nowhere has that been more commercially visible than in the reformulation of chocolate. The wave of consumer frustration with reformulated chocolate products is not simply about sugar reduction or calorie adjustment. It’s about the loss of kokumi. A greasy mouthfeel, an intense and one-dimensional sweetness that sits on the surface of the palate rather than developing through it: these are the hallmarks of a kokumi deficit. Consumers feel it viscerally even when they can’t articulate why the product no longer tastes right. The nutrition panel may have improved. The eating experience has not.
This is the work that sits at the centre of my approach to recipe development and product design. Working at the intersection of food science and satiety- the felt experience of true physical and mental fullness- I use kokumi alongside umami as a 360-degree framework for building food that satisfies deeply without relying on excess. The two work in concert: umami delivers the savoury depth that signals nourishment; kokumi provides the richness and persistence that makes an eating occasion feel complete. When both are present, food is satisfying in the truest sense. When either is absent, reformulation that is sound on paper tends to fail in the mouth.
For product developers, the practical implication is this: kokumi compounds are measurable, designable, and sourced from real ingredients such as fermented foods, aged proteins, allium extracts, slow-reduced stocks. They don’t require synthetic intervention. But they do require that sensory depth and texture richness be part of the development brief from the beginning, not added to rescue a formulation that’s already nutritionally locked.
Texture Now Has to Work Harder, Not Just Taste Clean
The GLP-1 shift has raised the stakes further. As appetite suppression changes both portion size and taste sensitivity, reporting from FoodNavigator-USA notes that GLP-1 users are specifically rejecting products with textures described as “really hard” or “really thick”, pushing formulators toward what’s being called “Goldilocks reformulations”: textures engineered to hold up as food cools, and formats designed around slower eating in smaller portions. As taste sensitivity dulls more broadly, indulgence is moving away from pure flavour intensity and toward multi-sensory experience, where texture, aroma, and visual appeal carry more of the emotional weight than flavour alone.
The implication for better-for-you NPD is clear: when consumers are eating less overall, each bite is under more pressure to deliver satisfaction. Texture isn’t a secondary consideration to nutrition anymore. It may be the primary lever.
This plays out at the clean label level too, where the trade-offs get harder, not easier. According to Kerry market research, 68% of consumers who read nutrition labels focus specifically on sugar content, yet reducing sugar is one of the most texture-disruptive changes a formulator can make. Clean label isn’t just a regulatory or labelling exercise; it’s a sensory one. Consumer acceptability has to be considered just as heavily as the ingredient swap itself, or the “better-for-you” version simply won’t get eaten twice. Naming an ingredient’s function on the label as “guar gum for texture,” for instance, has become one of the few accepted ways to be transparent about reformulation without losing the very texture agents that make the product work.
Why Texture Is What Turns a Trial Into a Habit
There’s a reason “good to the last bite” became a compliment, not just a slogan. Research on eating psychology has long shown that the first bite of food delivers the strongest sensation, and every bite afterwards delivers slightly less pleasure, which means the products that keep satisfaction high across the whole eating occasion, not just the first mouthful, are the ones that earn repeat purchase.
This holds even for markedly unfamiliar textures. A ten-week in-home study of plant-based meat substitutes found that repeated exposure to distinct, unfamiliar textures like tofu or Quorn eaten twice weekly over ten weeks actually increased acceptance among a segment of consumers over time (Hoek et al., 2013). Texture familiarity can be built. But only if the first few encounters aren’t off-putting enough to stop someone trying again.
Culture adds another layer developers can’t ignore. A comparative study of Chinese and Danish consumers found that what drives post-ingestive food pleasure differs meaningfully between markets . Danish consumers were strongly influenced by satiety-related sensations, while Chinese consumers were more driven by vitality-related states like feeling energised or relaxed (Duerlund et al., 2020). Similarly, research on oat products found that Finnish consumers rated porridge-style textures as “natural” and “healthy,” while the same textures were described as “strange” by Chinese consumers (Laaksonen et al., 2020). A texture that reads as premium in one market can read as unfamiliar or perhaps even off-putting in another.
The Indulgence Parallel
This isn’t only a “healthy food” problem. The same texture-first thinking is reshaping indulgence. Confectionery is shifting from “more is more” to “worth it,” with consumers prioritising quality over quantity: reduced sugar formulations, portion-controlled formats, and functional benefits layered into treats rather than stripped out of them.
And this is where kokumi re-enters the picture directly. The outrage around reformulated chocolate is a kokumi story. Richness, depth, and persistence are precisely what consumers are mourning, even when they lack the vocabulary to name it. Brands like Tony’s Chocolonely, and closer to home, Grá Chocolates, Tara Gartlan, bon chocolatier, and Bean and Goose, have shown that consumers will pay more when a product earns its price through the eating experience, not just the ingredient list. Not worth it on the nutrition panel. Worth it in the mouth- the snap, the melt, the depth that lingers. Texture, kokumi, and craft working together in ways that price-per-gram alone never could.
What This Means for NPD
The brief for better-for-you food can no longer start and end with the nutrition panel. Texture has to be part of the earliest development conversation and not a problem to solve once the “healthy” version already exists. That means investing in the food science (oral tribology, structural stabilisers, kokumi design from the brief stage) to protect and build mouthfeel through reformulation; understanding that GLP-1 users and ageing populations are placing new performance demands on every single bite; and recognising that texture preferences, like the sensation of kokumi itself, are cultural, contextual, and deeply personal.
Get the nutrition right and a product might get tried. Get the texture and the richness beneath it right, and it gets bought again.
References
- Duerlund, M., et al. (2020). Comparing Chinese and Danish consumers’ post-ingestive food pleasure. https://doi.org/10.3390/foods9050617
- Feron, G., & Salles, C. (2018). Food oral processing in humans: links between physiological parameters, release of flavour stimuli and flavour perception of food https://doi.org/10.7455/ijfs/7.1.2018.a1
- Hoek, A. C., et al. (2013). Replacement of meat by meat substitutes. Appetite https://doi.org/10.1016/j.appet.2011.02.001
- IFT Food Technology Magazine. Retaining Ingredient Functionality in Clean Label Products
- Kerry. Umami and Kokumi
- Laaksonen, O., et al. (2020). Cross-cultural sensory perception of oat-based products. https://doi.org/10.3390/foods9091234
- Psychology Today. The First Bite Is the Best
- ScienceDirect. Oral tribology and texture in healthy ice cream formulation
- Wang, Y., & Chen, J. (2017). Oral processing and sensory perception mechanisms. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0950329318302027
- Yan, W., et al. (2021). Microparticulated soy protein hydrolysates and xanthan gum in reduced-fat ice cream. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0260877420303794



